Funky Grandma >> Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 12:49, Τροποποιήθηκε Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 12:59

Has anyone experimented with having a versatile defender (possibly with long-shots), playing him as a DM? What do people think of this?

I wonder if it's more viable than spending a midfielder's resources on both his passing and his duelling... Just focus on the duelling and give him versatile.

(I realise that his star-value will appear very low in the match analysis, but that's not going to affect the match-engine result)

Numpty >> Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 13:48, Τροποποιήθηκε Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 14:14

Versatile on a DM will give him Scoring and not Passing. 

So a DM with lots of Duelling and no Passing - then Versatile will give him zero Scoring (which comes from his Passing).

Edit

Just to be clear. It's the playing position that counts for Versatile, not the kind of player that the game says he is. 

Funky Grandma >> Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 15:57, Τροποποιήθηκε Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 16:00

@Numpty: That's what I am uncertain about really. Are you sure that's how it is when it comes to how Versatile works? What makes you think that it's the position and not the type of player?

Edit

Ah, nevermind, you're right judging by the explanation of Versatile here: https://rockingsoccer.com/en/soccer/help/home/category-2/article-8.

Thank you for the response! :)

Numpty >> Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 16:36

Yes, it's in the Help. 

I guess if it worked the way you hoped it did then everyone would train their DMs that way. 

That's not to say that a DM with loads of Duelling is not a bad idea. They just can't pass very well. 

Angeldust >> Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 17:00

I think it was discussed when Versatile was introduced that this would indeed overpower DMs. 

I guess Vandermeersch won't be playing DM against me in de Cupfinal this evening!? :-)

Funky Grandma >> Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 23:47, Τροποποιήθηκε Παρασκευή Αύγουστος 14 - 23:47

@Angeldust

You guessed right :)

I tried to come up with a good solution, but I lost all the simulated matches with everything that I tried.

Well deserved win, congratulations! ^^

And congrats on the double too!

Angeldust >> Σάββατο Αύγουστος 15 - 21:29

Thanks, appreciate it! 
Glad to see a good manager take over a team in the Belgian league.