Numpty >> Понедельник Декабрь 9 - 09:09, Отредактирован Понедельник Декабрь 9 - 09:10

@Angel

How many position trainings are you intending to do? 

Even if you do 10 you still won't get back all the xp spent on Duelling, although you will get most of it and he would become a very decent AM.  

I think the answer really depends on what kind of player you need most and what else you are intending to buy. 

PMK >> Понедельник Декабрь 9 - 10:15

Well if you do 10 retrainings you will end up with 6,17balls in passing and 1,5balls in tactics. If you think it is enough passing for an AM at this age in your team, then you could retrain him.

Angeldust >> Понедельник Декабрь 9 - 12:16

@Numpty: my needs and transfer targets can change depending on what kind of player he becomes as well, so at this point I just wanted to see how I could get the most out of this guy.

I'm not that good with numbers, so I didn't have any idea how he would have turned out after 5 or 10 position trainings to be honest. 
I expected him to have some more passing in the end, so that will probably solve my dilemma... :-) 
DM seems like the most sensible thing. 

Numpty >> Понедельник Декабрь 9 - 17:20, Отредактирован Понедельник Декабрь 9 - 17:28

Okay, if it's a case of getting the most out of him then, as @PMK has already said, I think the simple answer is to keep him as a DM.  

It's not terribly cost-effective to change a player that's already been trained another way. 

Looking at the numbers in more detail his Duelling is currently 3.97 which should equate to a base value of 81 Duelling and also 3.75 (=75) Tactics.  For players over 21 there is a maximum limit of 10 position trainings, so if you did 10 then you would reduce Duelling to 31 and Tactics to 25 which you can retrain a little and then spend the rest of the xp on Passing. But he won't be as good an AM as he might have been because of the 'wasted' xp that's still on Duelling. 

If you keep him as a DM then I would suggest making sure he has as much Duelling as possible, since their main job is to tackle. Since you're happy to do some position trainings then I would reclaim some the xp spent on Passing to train more Duelling.

In this game most players are best trained as specialists, and those with multiple skills are not great at anything. DMs need to be very good tacklers and do not have to be good passers.  

Awful >> Четверг Август 6 - 15:14

https://rockingsoccer.com/en/soccer/info/player-2135409

what do you think guys  ? shielding + correct or dribbler +correct ?

Numpty >> Четверг Август 6 - 16:42

I would prefer Shielding. 

Why did you train both Versatile and Longshots?

Awful >> Четверг Август 6 - 19:48

why not ? this is the best combo for midfield to score !

Numpty >> Четверг Август 6 - 20:20, Отредактирован Четверг Август 6 - 20:31

I'm not saying it's wrong just trying to understand the reasoning. Maybe he will score more that way. 

Here's my thinking (for what it's worth) ...

Longshots - they can shoot and score outside the penalty area.

• Scoring = Passing. 

Versatile -  allows them to score inside the penalty area as well

• Passing gets a 0.15 penalty
• Not so good at providing assists
• Scoring from Longshots also gets a 0.15 penalty
• Scoring (inside the box) = Passing - 0.3

So it's a trade-off. 

Possibly getting some extra goals when inside the box and fewer assists and fewer goals outside the box. 

Is it worth it?

My personal view - without direct evidence - is that it's not worth it and Versatile will probably make him worse. But willing to consider any counter arguments.

Awful >> Пятница Август 7 - 12:18

what you think doesnt bother me at all

PMK >> Пятница Август 7 - 12:28

I would go dribbling and correct and play him AM/LAM/RAM. 

Awful >> Пятница Август 7 - 12:35, Отредактирован Пятница Август 7 - 14:09

thanks PMK !  mbe i will give him penalty taker speciality after dribbling, and then correct. hes not someone who benifits from  shielding much (no dueling, not dirty) ok, low tactics, but anyways . great team need better suited shielding guys, to earn free kicks and penalty shoots ..

Numpty >> Пятница Август 7 - 13:50, Отредактирован Суббота Август 8 - 11:18

"i started dribbling this morning ..."

You're welcome. :)

I would suggest going to see your doctor about the dribbling though. It can be a symptom of some serious illnesses. 

Aad Mansveld >> Пятница Август 7 - 14:24

i should go for shielding and correct. 

and versatile i.love it .extra striker on midfield or even winger .  Less assists but mire goals. Adding longshots is also a fine extra skill. Dont know if dribbling us worth the zp you will miss in passing though

Awful >> Пятница Август 7 - 14:33

thanks bro,  he will be the greatest attacking midfielder game has ever seen!